7 users responded in this post

Subscribe to this post comment rss or trackback url
User Gravatar
Julia Smith said in April 2nd, 2011 at 12:13 pm

One can only hope that these were once on a banned list and are now off of it.

Winnie the Pooh?!?!?
Charlotte’s Web?!?!?
The Wind in the Willows?!?!?
Wizard of Oz?!?!?

All of which I read while still a child, I might add. As for whether I’m for or against banning – I’m Canadian, and there tends to be less grass-roots pressure to ban things here. Thank heaven!

On your list of classics, my husband is at this very moment reading Catcher in the Rye and keeps wondering what the whole uproar once was about it.

Other than the kids’ books, the only other books on this list I’ve read are:

Gone With the Wind
On the Road
The Old Man and the Sea
The War of the Worlds

I remember reading “Catcher in the Rye” when I was in high school and even then I didn’t really understand what all the hoopla was about. Amazing what people will get their panties in a twist over.

User Gravatar
Mercy said in April 2nd, 2011 at 9:57 pm

Some of them I understand why they were banned at that time, others I think were just an obsene over reaction.

Why was the Wind in the Willows banned?

Good question. I haven’t read it recently, but I do have a copy, I’ll have to go back and see if I can figure it out.

User Gravatar
Linda Ann - Nickers and Ink said in April 3rd, 2011 at 8:09 am

OK, I admit it. I just counted, and I have read 62 of these!

What a reading rebel I must be … or a lit major.

Linda Ann

I stopped by via the A to Z Challenge for April, and I invite you to visit my blogs at:

NICKERS AND INK – poetry, humor, inspiration and more

PRACTICALLY AT HOME – inspiration, humor and how-tos for family, home and garden, and more

THE MANE POINT – a haven for horse lovers

You go girl!! Thanks for stopping by and thanks for your links too!

User Gravatar
Cheryl Malandrinos said in April 3rd, 2011 at 10:45 pm

I’ve never been for banning books, regardless of content. It goes against the freedoms America was founded on. While I agree some books require parental intervention, and some on this list I’ve read and thought were plain awful, I would never expect them to be banned.

I agree, parental intervention is one thing, banning is something else.

User Gravatar
Laurita said in April 6th, 2011 at 6:48 am

I’ve read about a third of these books. In fact, five of them are books we studied in school. Some of them I can see people not wanting to read, or even being a little offended, but banning? Some I can’t understand at all. Charlotte’s Web? Winnie the Pooh? Seriously.

Exactly…those two in particular…I don’t get it.

User Gravatar
klasko said in April 6th, 2011 at 8:07 am

Wow! So many of them I had to study in high school English classes. I have either read or know the story of about 2/3 of them.

I don’t think books should be banned, but read with discernment. Some of the banned books I just didn’t care for, and one in particular (a best seller), I didn’t think it was a particularly good story and wondered what all the hype was about. It has mature themes and controversial topics/characters.

Controversial topics are always ripe for talk of banning. As you know, I wrote my own controversial piece and have been met with mixed reviews even among my friends. It has never been published. Sometimes I think lack of publication is a form of book banning by those who want to dictate what they think the market will (or will not) support.

Some hot topics sell on the basis of their notoriety and how far they push the envelope of what is acceptable. Some are just third rails.

Some of the books mentioned, I just don’t get why.

Spot on, Karen.

User Gravatar
Linda said in April 6th, 2011 at 10:04 am

From what I have read, the children’s books are banned by different groups and countries. I don’t think the USA has a USA Banned Book List like a State Department warning of countires you may visit. Don’t know if it is true but they say piglet offends some religeous/cultural groups. They say Russia has banned Winnie-the-Pooh too.
To each his own—If I am offended, I just don’t read it. I like it like that.

Leave A Reply

 Username (Required)

 Email Address (Remains Private)

 Website (Optional)