Amazingly Annoying Alliteration
Posted by vrleavittJan 27
This morning I was discussing my latest audiobook experience with my husband. I very much like the story, but my one complaint is the frequent use of alliteration. Alliteration, of course, is the use of the same sound at the beginning of words in close quarters. Such as, beautiful bouncing baby boy.
A lot of authors use it and many how-to books and writing coaches encourage it as a useful tool in your writing. So what’s so annoying about it? Now get ready, because I don’t usually get too opinionated here. For me personally, it makes the words stand out too much. In some cases, that’s fine. A lot of entertainers or character names have alliteration. See also, Mickey Mouse, Lucy Lawless and Nicholas Nickelby. (How’s that for a strange cross section of people?)
Anyway, in those cases, it works great! You want your name to stand out, so by all means, alliterate away! But mid-paragraph descriptions in novels, I just don’t think it works. Example: “She walked up the steep, seemingly solid staircase.” Besides the fact that that is one of the worst sentences I’ve ever written, I think the nest of S’s is distracting. Instead of thinking about the staircase, or the peril the character may or may not be in, I’m thinking, “Wow. That’s a lot of S’s.” Two might be good, but three plus and you’re walking that lame, laborious line.
As my husband pointed out, it also works for tabloid headlines, because again, you want those to stand out.
Bat Boy Becomes a Baseball Player!
You get the idea.
Will I stop reading a book if it has alliteration? Of course not. For me, it’s all about story. But…is it annoying for me personally? Yes.
What are your thoughts? Do you consciously use alliteration? When reading, does it distract you or am I alone in this thing? (I could be! I won’t hold it against you if I am.) As always, I’d love to hear your thoughts.
7 comments
Comment by Wolf Althuis on January 27, 2010 at 3:59 pm
Amen! There’s nothing that will pull me out of a story faster than a lousy lump of languishing letters.
But like you said, it does have its place ocassionally.
Comment by Susan on January 27, 2010 at 9:39 pm
Love that string of “L” words! I honestly can’t remember any annoying alliteration in any of the books I’ve read or listened too. Guess I’m just lucky or it was only once in awhile so it silently slipped strategically unnoticed! I like to use in it my blog categories like my “Cosmo Considers” or “Dissection of a Drawing” but like you said, it’s used sparingly here and I think appropriately.
I’ll mention one of the many things that does annoy me in literature though and that’s over using phrases/words a LOT in novels. I’m a big believer in the thesaurus and I think authors sometimes get lazy and their editors don’t seem to care. I’ve noticed it in well established writers like Lincoln Child. I’ve read/listened to a few of his books and I’ve lost count how many times he uses the word “proferred”. In the latest YA book “Starclimber’ by Kenneth Oppel (who I really enjoy), he describes everything in space as a “maze of this” and a “maze of that”, like there are no synonyms for these words or phrases – lazy!
Anyway, thanks VR!
Comment by Karen Laskowsky on January 28, 2010 at 7:53 am
Hey V –
I agree with Susan about overused phrases. As writers, we all have our pet “go to” phrases, but we must be careful how and when we use them. (And know when it’s time to find a new pet phrase)
As for alliteration, I try to stay away from it unless I am teaching and want to use it as a mnemonic device. Then I try to keep it from being too corny.
Alliteration can be fun and whimsical in children’s books. Children love so say alliterative and rhyming words, sometimes the goofier the better. Who doesn’t love Dr. Seuss?
In more serious works, it’s right up there next to dimwitticisms.
Comment by Janet on January 28, 2010 at 10:38 am
I use alliteration in my picture book manuscripts and poetry, but stay away from it in my other writing.
Comment by VR Leavitt on January 28, 2010 at 10:57 am
Karen, good to hear from you!
I agree with you and Susan and everybody else too. It has it’s place…particularly in children’s books and of course poetry.
Thanks everybody for weighing in!
Comment by G.P. Ching on January 29, 2010 at 8:52 pm
I think alliteration is great for picture books, poetry, and headlines. I don’t use it (on purpose anyway) in young adult or adult works. I find it annoying and distracting as well.
Pingback by Friday Flasher :Coffee and a Keyboard on April 9, 2010 at 11:58 am
[...] been toying with the idea of participating in the #fridayflash phenomenon. (Pardon the slight alliteration. Couldn’t be [...]